Gifts for the Woman Who Has Everything, Including a Bathtub
Fourteen gifts for the woman who has everything: what other givers bought on what she said in passing, who each is wrong for, and five ideas we don't sell.
ReadA month in, a Christmas gift should be small. A few years in, it can be a trip. The table sorts the ideas by stage. The people quoted below either asked Reddit what to give a girlfriend or bought something of ours for a partner.
| How long | The rule | One idea |
|---|---|---|
| A few weeks to a few months | Small, specific, under $50 | Flowers wrapped in brown paper, and a date you plan |
| Six months to two years | A better version of something she uses every day | A trip to unwrap, or the bath tray if she reads in the tub |
| Living together | Something for your evenings at home that is still hers | A full-length bath pillow, or a chore you take off her list |
| Years in | Effort she can see | The photo album of your year, or a whole bath kit in one box |

Someone asked Reddit what to get a woman they had been seeing for about a month, something nice "but not coming off too strong." The highest-scoring answer was blunt: "Don't go crazy these should be items under $50. DO NOT BUY JEWELRY OR INTIMATE ITEMS." Another commenter explained why: "Going too big too soon on gifts could get unsustainable, or worse, could get cringe-y in the months ahead." One went further: "Why do you need to give her a gift. You hardly know each other."

A box of bath bombs, if you already know she takes baths. Our Natural Bath Bombs Gift Set is four 4-ounce bombs, one each of eucalyptus, lavender, lemongrass and rose, and it costs under $50 ($38.95). Fernando: "girlfriend loved the whole package." The lavender and rose ones leave buds and petals in the water to gather at the drain afterwards. Wrap it yourself. If you don't know yet whether she is a bath person, the flowers are the safer bet.

By now you know her routine, and the best advice in another girlfriend thread works from it: "Upgrade stuff she uses every day, like her water bottle, headphones, umbrella, or a good kitchen knife." That thread's original poster had ruled out photo frames, then gave her one anyway, filled with photos from her childhood, and came back to report: "SHE REALYYY LOVVVEDD IT."

The tray, if she reads or watches something in the bath. Three buyers have reviewed our Bamboo Bathtub Tray as a gift for a girlfriend. James: "My girlfriend is so In love with this surprise I got her". Jake: "My girlfriend absolutely loves it!" Samuel's girlfriend loves it too, with one caveat: "its a little big even in the smallest mode. We have a medium bath however its not even an issue." It rests across the rim and slides from 29.4 to 41.3 inches, with a stand for a book or tablet, a slot for a wine glass and a soap dish. It comes in its own printed box, and it is $68.95.

The bath pillow, if her evening ends in the tub. Ian gave our Bathtub Pillow "as a Christmas present for my GF, and she absolutely loves it." It is a mesh pillow with a rolled headrest that holds to the tub wall with seven suction cups, and it goes in the washing machine. Press every cup onto a clean, wet wall before the water goes in, and skip it if her tub is stone or textured. It is $44.90.

Now you share a bathroom, so you know her tub, and you also share a front door. Nathan's pillow was meant to be a Christmas present for "my wife but the obvious packaging it came in to our door was NO surprise." If she might be home when it arrives, have it sent somewhere she isn't.

A full-length bath pillow. Aly on our Full Body Bath Pillow: "My gf loves it! She’s been wanting something like this for a while because she loves baths." Chris bought one after "having a hard time shopping for a relaxing Christmas gift for my wife," and said our site was "insanely easy for someone like me that doesnt know much about relaxing bath time." It is 48 inches long and holds with 17 suction cups, so measure her tub's inside length first. Hayden wrote that their fiancé likes it but "mentioned that some of the suction cups fell off easily. They are able to be put back on tho." It is $68.90.

The pillow and the tray together. Sold as the Bath Tray and Bath Pillow, for $113.90. One buyer gave the pair for Christmas and wrote that "The pillow is comfortable but slips and slides around," and that the tray "broke in half already" because a "32 oz stanley cup full of water was too much for the glue joint." It is a tray for a glass and a book, not a full tumbler. The tray comes in its box and the pillow in its bag, in one shipping box, with no gift box.

After a few Christmases, the obvious things have been bought. The answers in the threads for this stage are about effort she can see.

A whole bath kit in one box. The Romantic Spa Gift Set is five pieces in our printed gift box on kraft shred: a rose bath bomb, rose bath salts, a jasmine body oil, a Rose Sandalwood candle and a black raspberry vanilla soap, for $86.75. It has no reviews yet. The bigger option, the Luxurious Bath Lover's Set, puts the bath pillow, the bamboo tray, a Palo Santo candle and three jars of bath salts in one order, for $221.65.

The clearest number in these threads is the first-month one: under $50. Past the first month, the answers are about fit rather than price: something tied to what she uses, what she likes, or what you have done together. The ideas on this page run from things that cost very little (flowers, a date, a printed album, a chore) to the six-piece bath set.
Six months to two years in, and she reads in the bath? The tray. Three buyers on this page gave it to a girlfriend, and the only problem any of them reported was its size. It slides from 29.4 to 41.3 inches, so measure her tub from rim to rim before you order.
Continue your ritual
One more read. One thing for the bath.